Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Only $0.18 goes to ICANN, the non-profit. The rest goes to the Verisign which is a publicly traded for-profit company which ultimately gets that $9.59. I bring this up because it of course _doesn't_ cost that much. Incidentally, Verisign posted $1.56 billion in revenue last year and spent about $1.21 billion on stock buybacks in the same time.


As I understand it, Verisign doesn't own the .com TLD, they are just a contracted service provider to ICANN.

Which begs the question, why doesn't ICANN just replace Verisign them with a different authoritative register that charges much less?


Because that doesn’t solve the problem. The demand doesn’t go away if you charge less – if you charge $1/yr for .COMs, they will all be permanently squatted. (Well, like now, but worse!)

We could use anti-scalping techniques, but that’s non-trivial to implement. Perhaps some name squatting policy? No idea how to enforce it though, especially without money.


Fair enough, but even we use a floor price to disincentivise squatting, I'm not sure why we should gift those excess margins to a private company?

Shouldn't ICANN collect that margin and use it for charitable purposes instead?


Yeah, that’s a good point. Then again, you can also that for any other gTLD (why should Google get the proceeds from .dev?), and that would be a valid question.

I think the current system is inherently flawed... but it kinda works, and nobody wants to figure out the politics of fixing it – so I guess we’re stuck with it for a while.


> nobody wants to figure out the politics of fixing it

The vast majority of people in the world have $0 on the line and no clue how these systems work.

The majority who have an interest in fixing it have something like N×$10 per year on the line for a fairly small N.

Those who don't want it fixed have billions on the line.

It's not getting fixed anytime soon.


That’s a “$1.56 billion” question…




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: