Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I honestly don't know what hockey Dryden is watching here. The game has gotten faster, and the players smaller over the last decade and a half. Most goals are tip shots, one timers, dekes, or power play goals. I agree that the goalie equipment size is out of whack, especially compared to what came before, but the rest of what he said makes me think he hasn't watched hockey since the 90s.


Goalie equipment rules are the same or more restrictive than in the past (pads are more narrow than they were allowed before). The difference is that current goalies in NHL are HUGE. When I see how tall they are when they are on their knees... OMG, I'm that tall when I stand in the crease. Catcher and blocker sizes are given and the same for everyone. The difference is with pad size where total height is limited by lengths of your bones so tall goalies can effectively have much larger pads. So, not only they are already big and block a big portion of the net, they block even more space because their pads are allowed to be much taller and thus blocking even more net.


yes, the biggest players on the ice these days are the goalies. The rest of the narrative about everyone crashing the net to get a goal seems false by my eye. The high slot tip was popularized in the last decade for instance.


For comparison sake, lacrosse goalies have bigger equipment, and a smaller net, and yet let in way more goals per game than any NHL game.


Lacrosse has a larger net, and goalies have far less and smaller equipment.


I was talking about box lacrosse, not field:

https://laxgoalierat.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/BoxLacro...


I am a dumb American. I didn't even know Box Lacrosse was a thing. We only have field lacrosse here.


lol. All of my favourite box lacrosse players had to go play box lacrosse in the US to actually make some money. You have a National Lacrosse League. Although I just checked, and there are a bunch more Canadian teams in that league than there used to be. At one point in the mid 2000s, 12 of the 14 teams were US based.


There are differences between indoor box hockey up in Canada and the open field variety more common in the US (both countries play both of course)


Field hockey is present in the US, but ice hockey is far more popular. This article is about the US/Canadian top-level ice hockey league... I can't say I've ever heard of professional field hockey play in the US, much less a nation-wide league.


They meant box lacrosse.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: